fill my day Coming to BristolComing soon

PLUMBING PROBLEMS

Toilet keeps running: what's wrong and what to do

Why a toilet keeps running or refilling on its own, the two parts usually to blame, and when it's worth calling a plumber.

IN SHORT

A toilet that keeps running almost always has one of two faults. Either water is leaking past the flush valve seal into the pan, or the fill valve isn't shutting off and water is escaping down the overflow. Lift the cistern lid and look: if the water level reaches the overflow, it's the fill valve; if it doesn't but the pan keeps trickling, it's the flush seal. Both are usually small, cheap repairs.

This page is part of our guide to common plumbing problems.

The two usual causes

Almost every running toilet comes down to one of two parts inside the cistern.

  • The flush valve. At the bottom of the cistern, a seal holds the water in until you flush. When it wears or gets limescale on it, water trickles past into the pan. The cistern level drops, and the toilet refills itself, often every few minutes.
  • The fill valve. This lets water back in after a flush and shuts off when the cistern is full. Older toilets use a ball valve with a float on an arm. If the valve doesn't close, water keeps rising and escapes down the overflow, into the pan or out of a pipe outside.

How to tell which one it is

Take the lid off the cistern and wait for it to fill. You don't need to touch anything yet.

  1. Look at the water level

    If it rises to the top of the overflow pipe and keeps going, the fill valve isn't shutting off.

  2. Look in the pan

    If the water level in the cistern stays below the overflow but you can see a constant trickle running down the back of the pan, the flush valve seal is leaking.

  3. Listen

    A toilet that goes quiet, then hisses briefly every so often, is usually a slow flush valve leak being topped up.

Some fill valves have an adjustment screw or clip that sets how high the water fills. If it's set too high, lowering it slightly may stop water reaching the overflow. If the valve still runs, it needs replacing.

Stopping it for now

A running toilet isn't an emergency. To stop the noise and the waste until it's fixed, find the small isolation valve on the pipe feeding the cistern. Turn the slot a quarter turn with a flat screwdriver so it sits across the pipe, and the water stops. Turn it back to flush.

If there's no isolation valve, you can turn off the water at the stop tap, but that turns off the whole house. Fitting an isolation valve is something to ask the plumber to do at the same time.

Why it's worth fixing soon

A constant trickle adds up. If you're on a water meter, you pay for every litre. A fill valve that overflows can also send water out of an overflow pipe on an outside wall, which can stain or damage brickwork over time.

What the fix costs

Replacing a fill valve or ball valve typically costs £50 to £300, including parts but not VAT, according to Which?'s Trusted Traders. Simple swaps are at the bottom of that range. Concealed cisterns behind a wall cost more because the plumber has to get to them. Our guide to ball and fill valve costs has the full figures.

If the toilet is old and keeps needing repairs, it can make sense to replace it. See what a new toilet costs.

A running toilet is exactly the kind of small, non-urgent job Fill My Day is built for. It's coming soon to Bristol and isn't taking bookings yet. See what's launching in Bristol.

GOOD TO KNOW

Questions,
answered straight.

Why does my toilet keep running?

Usually because the flush valve seal at the bottom of the cistern is worn and lets water trickle into the pan, or because the fill valve doesn't shut off, so water keeps running into the overflow. Both parts wear out with age and limescale.

Why does my toilet refill on its own every few minutes?

That's normally a slow leak past the flush valve seal. Water seeps into the pan, the level in the cistern drops, and the fill valve tops it back up. Replacing the seal or the flush valve usually fixes it.

Is a running toilet an emergency?

No. It wastes water, but it's not urgent. If it's driving you mad, turn off the small isolation valve on the pipe feeding the cistern until it's fixed, and turn it back on to flush.

How much does it cost to fix a running toilet?

Replacing a fill valve or ball valve is typically £50 to £300 including parts but not VAT, according to Which?'s Trusted Traders. See our full guide to fill valve costs.

FIRST STOP / BRISTOL

Bristol.
You’re up first.

The app is in development and isn't taking bookings yet. Plumbers first, other trades to follow.